Does Leaving Make You Free?

Series — Freedom Put to the Test

“Having a choice is what matters. Sleeping outside because you want to, not because you have to.”

I wrote that in a piece about self-reliance. I still mean it. There’s a real pleasure in thinking, tonight I feel like sleeping outside.

But since we’re talking about freedom, I might as well start by taking a hard look at my own certainties.

Two people sleep outside.

One because they really want to.

The other because they have nowhere else to go.

Same sky. Same mosquitoes.

A very different kind of freedom.

You can sing the praises of simplicity and getting back to basics all you like. It sounds lovely.

But a bed might do the second person more good than a speech.

That’s the difference. Having a choice means you can do something else.

Provided you actually can.


Are We Really Free to Choose?

On paper, we’re free to change careers, move somewhere else or start over.

An employee can turn down a transfer. That’s their right.

But with a loan to pay off and people counting on them, saying no comes at a price.

They can say no.

Can they afford to?

That’s a different question.

Our choices depend on what we can afford, our responsibilities, our health… and a whole lot of things we can’t control.

So telling everyone they “just have to want it” is a little too easy. And a little too comfortable, too.

Figures in ancient clothing watch shadows cast on a cave wall by a fire
What if the things we take for granted keep us from seeing anything else?

But here’s another contradiction.

If our commitments limit our options, should we avoid making any so we can stay free?


Building Things Was Part of My Freedom, Too

I spent twenty-five years in construction and running businesses. I built my own house, started projects and learned different trades.

And I loved it. Seeing a project take shape, learning to do something I couldn’t do the day before, building my own home… It made me proud and happy.

I could tell you now that all of it trapped me, that I finally opened my eyes and that I’m leaving to get my freedom back.

It would make a good story.

It would also be a lie.

At the time, building things, starting businesses and throwing myself into those projects was exactly how I exercised my freedom.

Yes, those choices closed other doors. That’s how commitment works. When you put your time and energy into one thing, you have less to put elsewhere.

So what?

Sometimes we spend years building the life we chose. Then one day we want to change it… and discover it doesn’t give easily.

That’s part of building something, after all. It holds.

That doesn’t make it a prison.

It doesn’t make it easy to change, either.

And above all, it doesn’t mean we got it wrong.

What suited us perfectly twenty years ago might no longer fit the people we’ve become.

Sometimes a few adjustments are enough. Sometimes we want a bigger change. Sometimes we simply choose to carry on.

There’s no one best way to live.

Staying doesn’t necessarily mean you’re trapped.

Leaving doesn’t automatically make you free.

An open hand holds a red pill and a blue pill against a dark background
Are we really free to choose?

So, What Does It Mean to Have a Choice?

I stand by what I said at the start.

At 5,300 m, above the sixth Gokyo lake, I’d planned to sleep outside. What a night to camp out! First came the moon over the snowy peaks. Then, in the morning, the first light turned them gold while the tent was still in shadow. It was breathtaking. I was so happy to be there. And yet I wouldn’t spend my life there. The cold made every little task harder. On a night like that, everything comes into focus. I could spend ages just watching the light change on the snow. After several nights of poor sleep, though, I know I’d mostly be thinking about how to get warm. And what a joy it is to get back to a warm bed! Rest does me good, and after a while it makes me want to head out again. Where’s the balance? It shifts from day to day. How do I tell when discomfort is still opening something up for me and when it’s time to head back? And when does the comfort that felt so good start to lull me to sleep?

Figure seen from behind under the moon, facing snowy peaks
Moonrise above the sixth Gokyo lake, at 5,300 m.

Having a choice matters.

But there can be a world of difference between the options we imagine and the ones we can actually act on.

And then there’s the awkward paradox. We exercise our freedom by making decisions that later limit it.

Should we build nothing and never commit to anything, just to keep every door open?

I don’t think so.

But I don’t think a choice we made yesterday has to lock us in for good tomorrow, either.

What I still have to figure out is what I want to change, what I want to keep, and what I’m willing to put into it.

These are the kinds of questions I want to start this series with.

I’m not looking for a new recipe for freedom.

I just want to take a closer look at what we mean by a word we sometimes use a little too quickly.

After all, if we’re free to choose our lives…

are we also free to change our minds?

And if we aren’t, how free were we to begin with?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *